Why do some people naturally pick up certain skills faster than others? Why do siblings raised in the same home sometimes have completely different personalities?
Psychologists study how our genes and experiences work together to shape who we are.
This is known as the nature vs. nurture debate.
Nature (Heredity): Refers to our genetic makeup; the DNA passed down from our parents.
Nurture (Environment): Everything from our family and friends to our culture and experiences.
Today, psychologists recognize that both nature and nurture influence our behavior, personality, and mental processes.
Modern view: Nurture works on what nature provides
I. Heredity and Environment
Our behavior, personality, and mental processes are influenced by both heredity (nature) and environment (nurture). These influences interact throughout our lives.
From an evolutionary view, humans developed ways to spot and react to danger quickly. Some fears, like of snakes or spiders, may be innate (we are naturally born with)
Example: Humans may learn to fear snakes more easily than harmless objects because avoiding dangerous animals helped our ancestors survive.
Heredity refers to the passing of genetic characteristics from biological parents to their children.
Genes influence physical traits, such as height and eye color.
Genes can also influence behavior, personality, and mental processes.
However, genes do not determine every aspect of who we become.
Environment includes the outside experiences and conditions that influence our development.
Examples:
Family relationships and parenting.
Education and access to learning opportunities.
Friends, culture, and community.
Nutrition, exercise, and living conditions.
Stressful or traumatic experiences.
A genetic predisposition is an inherited tendency that makes someone more likely to develop a particular trait or behavior.
Having a predisposition does not guarantee that a trait or behavior will develop.
Environmental factors can influence whether and how that tendency is expressed.
Example: Someone may inherit a greater risk of developing anxiety, but their experiences, support system, and environment can influence whether they develop an anxiety disorder.
Remember: Genes can influence what is more likely to happen, but they do not always determine what will happen.
Psychologists use different types of studies to understand how genes and experiences influence behavior.
Twin Studies: Compare identical and fraternal twins to study genetic and environmental influences.
Family Studies: Study how traits appear among family members.
Adoption Studies: Compare adopted children with their biological and adoptive families.
Twin studies compare identical and fraternal twins to investigate how genes and the environment influence traits and behavior.
Why Do Psychologists Study Twins?
Comparing twins helps researchers understand the possible influence of genetics.
If identical twins are more similar in a trait than fraternal twins, this suggests a genetic influence.
If identical twins differ despite sharing nearly all their DNA, environmental influences may help explain the differences.
Twins raised in different homes can provide additional evidence about heredity and environment
Identical Twins
100% same DNA
Fraternal Twins
50% same DNA
Adoption studies compare adopted children with their biological and adoptive families to investigate the influence of genes and environment.
Biological Parents: Share genes with the adopted child.
Adoptive Parents: Provide the child's home environment and upbringing.
What Can Adoption Studies Tell Us?
If adopted children resemble their biological parents in a particular trait, this suggests a genetic influence.
If adopted children resemble their adoptive parents, this suggests an environmental influence.
Examples:
An adopted child has a similar personality trait to their biological mother despite never growing up with her. This may suggest a genetic influence.
An adopted child develops similar study habits to their adoptive parents, suggesting that the home environment may influence learning behaviors.
Family studies examine how certain traits and behaviors appear among biological relatives.
Researchers examine whether traits are more common among people who are genetically related.
These studies can help identify patterns that may have genetic influences.
Example: Researchers discover that a psychological disorder is more common among close biological relatives of people who have that disorder.
The Galvin family, had 12 children, with 6 of them developing schizophrenia. In the case of the Galvin family, epigenetics could help explain why some siblings developed the disorder while others did not, despite sharing the same genetic background.
How to Interpret Research Findings
Identical twins are more alike than fraternal twins → genetic influence
Identical twins share nearly 100% of their genes, while fraternal twins share about 50%. If identical twins are more similar, genes likely play a role.
Identical twins raised apart show differences → environmental influence
Identical twins share nearly the same genes but grow up in different environments. Their different experiences may explain why they develop different traits.
Adopted children resemble biological parents → genetic influence
They share genes with their biological parents, even if they did not grow up together.
Adopted children resemble adoptive parents → environmental influence
They do not share genes with their adoptive parents, but they share a home, upbringing, and experiences that can shape their behavior.
Remember: These findings suggest that genes or environment play a role. They do not prove that either is the only cause.
Buck v. Bell (1927): The Supreme Court ruled that Virginia’s law allowing forced sterilization of people in mental institutions was constitutional. Carrie Buck, labeled “feeble-minded,” was ordered to be sterilized. The Court upheld the law, stating it would prevent the country from “being swamped with incompetence…Three generations of imbeciles is enough.” The decision has never been overturned.
Eugenics was a harmful movement that attempted to control human reproduction based on the belief that certain inherited traits were more desirable than others.
Supporters claimed that society could be improved by encouraging some people to reproduce while preventing others from having children.
Eugenics was used to justify discrimination, forced sterilization, and other human rights abuses.
These practices were based on discriminatory beliefs and misuses of genetic and evolutionary ideas
Epigenetics is the study of changes in how genes are expressed without changing the underlying DNA sequence.
Environmental factors can influence the activity of certain genes.
Examples:
Nutrition
Exposure to chemicals
Stress
Other environmental conditions
Example: Identical twins begin life with nearly identical DNA, but differences in their experiences and environments can contribute to changes in gene activity over time.
This helps explain why identical twins may become more different as they age.
Remember: Epigenetics does not mean experiences rewrite someone's DNA. It involves changes in how certain genes are regulated.
Picture suggestion: An existing diagram comparing identical twins and showing how different environments may influence gene expression.
2.1.A Explain the relationship between heredity and environment in shaping behavior and mental processes.
2.1.A.1 Heredity and the Environment
2.1.A.2 Evolutionary Perspective
2.1.A.3 Research: Twin studies, family studies, adoption studies
Brain Structures & Functions
Brain Lobes
Split Brain
Neuroplasticity & Brain Measurements